(keitai-l) Re: The truth about mobile data

From: cfb <chris_at_bryden.net>
Date: 11/20/01
Message-ID: <3BF9D994.5FF3511@bryden.net>
Juergen Specht wrote:
> 
> Oh my god, is this another "frustrated foreigner knows the
> final truth about Japan" thread? One list member provides his
> own list for this kind of talk.

Funny, I had a native Japanese person ask me "so chris, what
do you think the next 'big thing' will be for the Internet and 
Japan" just last month (and this guy is pretty tech savvy).   

I didn't have an answer for him (well, actually, I do have a few 
ideas, with the one or two lose marbles, rolling around in my 
otherwise empty head); one thing I have no shortage of, however,
is opinions.

> > And finally, why does docomo only have 2 class C's allocated to their
> > ENTIRE multibillion i-mode subscriber "service"?
> > Last I checked, that was only ~500 IP's, can't be that less than 500
> > people are using i-mode all over the entire japan at the same time, no?
> 
> Oh, wow. You are also a tech-specialist. Sorry to disappoint
> you, but you can hide hundreds of private Class A networks
> behind a single IP.

I suppose the tech. specs. for the NTT end of the gateways are 
floating around somewhere (and I don't mean through legitimate
sources, but I'm no Otaku... or whatever the ideogram for 
"Japanese cracker" is).  I guess that's part of the problem with
partially closed systems... one never knows *exactly* what is 
going on.

Anyway, several months ago, I had the opportunity to play around 
with a Checkpoint firewall installed at an ISP.  Since it was in a 
region where imode has low utilization and since there were no
significant imode sites hosted by the ISP, I was able to isolate my
imode access to the ISPs content down to a specific IP address.
The behavior was weird...  standard ICMP echo request/reply only
seemed to work while particular session was open and once
the content had been delivered the ICMP replies stopped (and 
re-appeared randomly as the IP address was resued for a 
different session).  This would seem to suggest some back-end
loadbalancing.... that much is obvious.

> I hope that no journalist reads your post and creates a new
> headline "DoCoMo Bankrupt! i-mode never had more than 500
> users!" :)

No, but I wouldn't mind seeing a headline reading "DoCoMo imode
Conceptually Bankrupt!  your phone doesn't have an IP address."

[ Need archives? How to unsubscribe? http://www.appelsiini.net/keitai-l/ ]
Received on Tue Nov 20 06:41:03 2001